Is Madewell Back?! 12 Pieces We Just Tried On That Are Classic But NOT Boring. Photos Galore!

They’re back.

 

If you buy something we link to, The Candidly may earn a commission. Gifted items will be called out (gifted), and affiliate links will include an asterisk (*). We have to eat, after all.

 

by The Candidly Team


Madewell is certainly classic. But classic can also mean … boring. We weren’t necessarily wowed the last few visits to be completely honest. 

 
 

But their winter edit is so elevated, so well-fitting, so FLATTERING, we nearly sprained our ankle running to tell you about it. And also almost everything is on a massive black Friday sale of 40% off. 

Here’s everything we found that’s classic but with an expected twist or fit, so as to never look boring. Let’s try it on!

 
 
 

1. This rugby shirt that’s actually VELOUR

WHAT: Velour Long-Sleeve Polo*

Soft as a lamb’s ear, and boxy enough to be tucked in or not tucked in. Quite cute with their new curvy barrel jeans* but I didn’t see much of a dif in fit from their regular barrel. 

 
 
 

Sizes for ref: Shirt in M, Jeans in 28 (I’m 5’6”)

Price: $59 $88


 
 

2. Trouser pants that actually fit at the waist on curves?!

WHAT: The Everyday Trouser in Black Grey Houndstooth*

Truly one of the better tailored and cut pants at an affordable price of all time. And they come in tons of cute colors and patterns. Here’s the full outfit with this very comfy and flattering t-shirt* and scarf*:

 
 
 

Sizes for ref: Trousers in 6, Tee in S (I’m 5’6”)

Price: $88 $148


 
 

3. The “I’m just a sweater and skirt” outfit that’s actually beyond 

WHAT: The Adelaide Mockneck Sweater in Cloudsoft* and Denim Midi Skirt*

This is, no joke, the softest sweater. It’s almost unreal. But what we loooooove is the little baby mock turtle that doesn’t feel suffocating but DOES hide our turkey neck! Happy thanksgiving! And is there a more flattering length for a denim skirt? We think not. Fine, the boots* do help.

 

Sizes for ref: Sweater in size S, Skirt in size 28 (I’m 5’6”)

Price: $76 $128 for the sweater, $71 $128 for the skirt


 
 

4. Here’s that sweater again because it’s imperative you understand how good it is. 

WHAT: The Adelaide Mockneck Sweater in Cloudsoft* and The Devon Pant in Charcoal Stripe*

SO SOFT, and it’s that material wear you can do a haphazard tuck like this and it looks good, or you can leave it untucked and it doesn’t look sloppy. And these gorgeous, pinstripe, loose pants* basically feel like pajamas—but they’re so chic and put together you could absolutely wear them to the dining room for your Thanksgiving feast. (And a stretchy elastic waist soooo spare no expensive with the stuffing.)

Sizes for ref: Pants in 6, Sweater in S (I’m 5’6”)

Price: $70 $118 for the pants

 

 
 

5. The outfit that we’d never wear but are now considering it because of this article

WHAT: Shirt-Jacket in Airy Denim* and The Low-Rise Loose Pant in Corduroy*

These 70ish corduroy pants* are considered low rise, but they’re so well cut they actually fit a non-Gen Z body! The t-shirt is a cropped long-sleeve* (and it’s so comfortable and perfect for more high-waisted pants if midriff exposure is not for you), and the denim shacket* feels androgynous in such a chic way. It’s also ideal if you’re always cold (us) but don’t want to sit at work wearing a huge winter coat. 

 

Sizes for ref: Shacket in S, Cords in 28, Tee in S (I’m 5’6”)

Price: $71 $128 for the shacket, $66 $138 for the cords


 
 

6. The delicate white blouse that’s verging on “the puffy shirt” except it’s actually gorgeous

WHAT: The Louisa Shirt* and The Perfect Vintage Wide-Leg Jean in Airy Denim* 

We are an always drawn to feminine, frou frou, pretty, delicate shirts, but we usually feel dumb wearing them. But this one is GORGEOUS and such soft cotton and can be worn slightly tucked or would be gorgeous with flare jeans and boots. Also please address yourself to the mind-melting color of those jeans…

Sizes for ref: Shirt in M, Jeans in 28 (I’m 5’6”)

Price: $65 $128 for the shirt, $88 $148 for the jeans


 
 
 

7. The “study in green” monochrome outfit that we had to buy immediately 

WHAT: The Boxy Easy Shirt in 100% Cotton Corduroy* and The Perfect Vintage Wide-Leg Jean in Airy Denim*

And speaking of those green jeans* that we bought immediately because we didn’t realize perfectly fitting, forest green jeans were the missing piece in our winter wardrobe, but here we are—they are gorgeous paired with this also forest green, cropped, cord shirt*. Also, the jeans are made with something called “airy denim” so they’re extremely soft and not at all rigid, and so they sort of feel like you’re wearing nothing at all. Here they are that very evening to show that even though this is just “jeans and a sweater” it’s actually not. 

 

Sizes ref: Top in S, Jeans in 28 (I’m 5’6”)

Price: $58 $98 for the shirt, $88 $148 for the jeans


 
 

8. The “cool girl” trucker jacket we can barely pull off

WHAT: Sherpa-Lined Utility Denim Jacket* and The Perfect Vintage Wide-Leg Jean*

Still unsure if this works but it’s so warm and so comfortable and we really, really want it to. Also those are the same jeans as the green above and they are just as perfectly cut, though apparently these are NOT the same “airy denim” though we couldn’t tell the diff. Don’t be afraid of white—they’re crisp and flattering.

Sizes for ref: Jacket in S, Jeans in 28 (I’m 5’6”)

Price: $148 $248 for the jacket, $88 $148 for the jeans

 

 
 

9. The most beautiful purple sweater possibly in existence 

WHAT: The Mila Sweater in 100% SoftWool* and The Perfect Vintage Wide-Leg Jean*

Ok. This might be the world’s most perfect color for anyone to instantly look like they had one year of sleeping a full 8 hours every night, while also somehow enjoying a subtle tan. It’s so enlivening and so joyful next to the face, it’s sort of impossible to be in a bad mood while wearing it. It’s also slouchy enough to tuck if you want but not so baggy that it looks sloppy if you don’t. And again with the white jeans—this is again just jeans and a sweater but the overall look is so crisp and chic.

Sizes for ref: Sweater in M, Jeans in 28 (I’m 5’6”)

Price: $58 $98 for the sweater, $88 $148 for the jeans

 

 
 

10. The dress I just figured out how to wear for anyone else who refuses to expose their knees 

WHAT: Johnny-Collar Drop-Shoulder Mini Dress* and The Everyday Trouser* 

You might hate this look and that’s fine—but we don’t love knee-exposure. But what we DO love is a slouchy, oversized, tunic-like, cozy dress when it’s cold outside and we feel as though we’ve cracked the code on how to wear them!

We threw them on over the baggy trousers* above and then used our own sweater to create a waist. Genius? Maybe! And if you’re wondering … yes, they’re extensions. Life changing.

 
 
 

Sizes for ref: Dress in M, Pants in 6 (I’m 5’6”)

Price: $80 $148 for the dress, $88 $148 for the trousers


 
 

At The Candidly, we try a lot of stuff so you don’t have to. We only recommend things we truly love, and that we think you’ll love, too. All products are chosen independently by our creative team, and all details reflect the price and availability of products at the time of publication. If you buy something we link to, The Candidly may earn a commission.
We have to eat.