6 Things In My Closet That I Love Dearly But Am Now Too Old To Wear. And 6 I Will Wear Til I'm Dead.
Just listed on FB Marketplace: 12 Urban Outfitters halter tops from 2004.
If you buy something we link to, The Candidly may earn a commission. Gifted items will be called out (gifted), and affiliate links will include an asterisk (*). We have to eat, after all.
by Carolyn Firestone
I know we’re all supposed to feel free and wear whatever we want, cause “we’re only as old as we feel,” “age is only a number,” etc. etc.
But no one wants to be the person who looks like they’re trying to look young by dressing like they’re still 16. Right?
Though who tells you when your clothes are starting to look too young for you? I’m 43, and I recently expressed this concern to one of my sisters, and she said, “well, you do wear a lot of midriff tops.” And she’s not wrong. Weirdly, I wouldn’t dare show my stomach as a self-conscious as 20-something who always wore her towel right up to the edge of the swimming pool. But since 35, I’m not bothered— a condition I refer to as my “midrife crisis.”
See? Would a young person make that joke?
Anyway, in a quest to maybe “class up” my wardrobe, I’ve done a purge of 6 items that felt a little too young (For me personally. I fault no one for loving and wearing these items at any age.) But because my quest also includes wanting to still dress kind of … is cool the right word? … and not age myself 15 years by prematurely entering my Costco sweatshirt, fanny pack, and capris era, I also included 6 things I’m very much still wearing— 6 things that feel flattering and youthful(ish) and most importantly, that feel like me.
Ok, for better or for worse, step into my closet:
1. What I Ditched: Belly-Bearing Tops
The Problem: Like I said, I love a cropped top. Truly. When it hits riiiiiiight at the top of your pants, it makes your legs look longer and your waist look simultaneously covered up and kind of shrunken. But some tops are just too cropped. Like lift-your-arms-and-your-boobs-fall-out-the-bottom cropped. And to those tops, I say farewell.
What I Kept: Short(ish) tees I Don’t Have To Tuck
WHAT: Z Supply Modern Slub Tee*
WHY IT WORKS: I still make sure my tees are not too long, because long tees can look sloppy and shapeless. This is my perfect-length tee that skims the waist so I don’t look wider. I own multiples of it in white cause it’s the only white tee I ever want to wear.
Price: $39
2. What I Ditched: Mini, mini Skirts
The Problem: No matter how I style a skirt this short, it makes me feel like I’m in the getup from “Hit Me Baby One More Time,” complete with knee socks and pigtails. And just the fact that I’m old enough to think that tells me I’m too old to be wearing it.
What i kept: A-Line Midi Skirts
WHAT: The Great The Canary Skirt*
WHY IT WORKS: Still feminine and youthful and yet as classic as Audrey Hepburn herself. This one from The Great is unbelievably luxe (the only skirt I’ve ever splurged on), and the wide band of smocking is a dream on my ever-fluctuating lower belly.
Price: $425
WHAT: Free People Lowen Midi Skirt*
WHY IT WORKS: I own this in almost every color it comes in. It is everything a poplin midi skirt should be. The waistband is smooth in the front but elastic in the back so it looks smart but feels like PJ pants.
Price: $60
3. What I Ditched: Sheer sweaters (also sheer anything)
The Problem: There’s never been a bra, bralette, or cami that doesn’t look lumpy underneath or that remotely erases my self-consciousness.
WHAT I WEAR INSTEAD: These COZY PIECES WITH A Youthy, Flattering Fit
What I Kept: Cozy Pieces With A Youthy, Flattering Fit
WHAT: Good American The Chunky Knit Sweater*
WHY: Apart from softness, shape is the most important thing with sweaters—the difference between it looking styled and looking frumpy. See how this one goes in at the bottom? Seeeee? The more you can get your clothes to give you an hourglass, the better. And this length looks perfect with all high-waisted pants.
Price: $158
WHAT: Nuuds Cinch Waist Sweatshirt*
WHY IT WORKS: Same goes for sweatshirts. I reach for this one constantly because it still looks like I’m wearing clothes as opposed to my other sweatshirts which come across very disheveled and potato sack-like.
Also again, no tuck needed!
Price: $88
4. What I Ditched: Short, Girlie Slack Dresses
The Problem: I used to love this shape of dress because it makes everyone look leggy but since I’ve gotten older, I find it just makes me look boxy and blah.
What I Kept: Foolproof Fit And Flare Dresses
WHAT: Quince 100% European Linen Button Front Dress*
WHY IT WORKS: What I lose In leg, I gain in silhouette. Fit and flare gives everyone their best hourglass, while covering the lower belly, hips, butt, whatever we don’t care to show off at that moment. This dress comes in TONS of colors and prints, but in winter, I wear it in gingham and swap sandals with tights* and boots*.
Price: $64
WHAT: Marcella Clara Dress*
WHY IT WORKS: The top is like a sculpting tank and the bottom is floaty poplin. The dream!
Price: $75
5. Flimsy Little Bralettes
The Problem: In a word, gravity.
What I Kept: Fully Supportive Mesh Bralettes
WHAT: EBY Madam Bralette*
WHY IT WORKS: We all wish we could wear what my boss calls a “dainty bralette” and this is indeed a dainty bralette … BUT … a supportive one. It’s mesh, so it’s alluring. It’s wireless, so it’s comfy. And it’s supportive, so you still get round, lifted shape.
Price: $44
6. What I Ditched: Tricky Front Cutouts
The Problem: The fear of certain parts of my body plotting some weird escape ALWAYS outweighs the cuteness of any cutout.
What I Kept: Off-Shoulder Tops
WHAT: Nation Kate Top*
WHY IT WORKS: The shoulders are where I’m most comfortable showing a peek of skin. This top feels sophisticated and understated, and it covers everything else, including my arms.
Price: $47
WHAT: Favorite Daughter The New Era Off the Shoulder Long Sleeve Jersey Maxi Dress*
WHY IT WORKS: Ok ok, I realize I’m breaking my own rule with the mesh, but this is that one, understated way I’m willing to wear something sheer. This dress covers the thick of the arm and the lower belly and keeps everything feeling held in and and comfortable while still feeling a whisper risqué.
Price: $216
7. What I Ditched: Strappy, Skinny Heeled Heels
The Problem: Pain! That’s it. Just pain.
What I Kept: Orthopedic party shoes
WHAT: Nisolo Luna Heeled Mary Jane*
WHY IT WORKS: I look for block heels and brands that cater to tired, old feet and people who act like babies about them. These are my favorites. The heel is endlessly supportive and not too high. And the MJ shape is very chic.
Price: $99
Carolyn is the Managing Editor of The Candidly. Her favorite thing to do is to write about her favorite things, especially when they have even the slightest chance of making someone else’s something (mood, relationship, travel plans, or toiletry kit) a little better. You can find more of her articles here.
At The Candidly, we try a lot of stuff so you don’t have to. We only recommend things we truly love, and that we think you’ll love, too. All products are chosen independently by our creative team, and all details reflect the price and availability of products at the time of publication. If you buy something we link to, The Candidly may earn a commission.
We have to eat.